Journal of Legal Research

Journal of Legal Research

Fairness and Justice in the Procedure of the Iran–United States Claims Tribunal

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD Student in International Law, Faculty of Law, Tehran North Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Faculty of Law, Tehran North Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
3 Associate Professor, Department of Public Law, Faculty of Islamic Studies and Law, Imam Sadiq University, Tehran, Iran; Invited, Department of International Law, Faculty of Law, Tehran North Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
Justice and fairness are the greatest goals of legal proceedings both in international courts and tribunals and in domestic courts. Equity and fairness are the center of gravity of foreign investment law, which aims to increase the flow of capital globally and improve economic relations between countries. Attracting foreign investment through gaining trust in the administration of justice in the judicial and arbitration system is very important for economic growth. Fairness has different functions and concepts. Sometimes it is known as a general legal principle and sometimes as ex aequo et bono and sometimes it is seen as a code of conduct and in foreign investment agreements as fair and equitable treatment. The views of the Iran-United States Claims Tribunal, which is 40 years old, are very important in various investment issues and the approach of the tribunal, as one of the most influential arbitration authorities in the international arena, is the goal of this article; by searching the opinions of the Court, it aims to clarify the position of fairness, ex aequo et bono and fair and equitable treatment in the decisions of the tribunal. Relying on contractual law and international law, the tribunal has the authority to resort to equity, ex aequo et bono and fair and equitable treatment. But among the concepts and functions of fairness, only equity has been invoked by the tribunal as a legal principle.
Keywords

  • Books:

    • Askari, Puria; Foreign investment rights in international arbitration procedure, Third edition, Tehran: Shahrdanesh Institute of Legal Studies and Research, 2014. (in Persian)
    • Bledsoe, Robert L., Boezek, Boleslaw A., Translator: Bahman Aghai, The International Law Dictionary, First Edition, Tehran , Gangedanesh Publication, 1996. (in Persian)
    • Brownlie, Ian, Principle of Public International Law, Fifth Edition, Clarendon Press, (1998), (in English)
    • Ghamami, Majid and Fahimeh Yadgari, International Investment Law: (Semantics of Foreign Investor and Investment), 1st edition, Tehran: Enteshar Co., 2018. (in Persian)
    • Khalilian, Sayyed Khalil, A Jurisprudential Study On the Iran-United States Claims Tribunal, Tehran: Enteshar Co., 2003. (in Persian)
    • Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar, Legal Terminology, 12th edition, Tehran: Ganj Danesh, 2011. (in Persian)
    • Marousi, Ali, Report of the decisions of the Iran-United States Claims Tribunal, (Tehran: Deputy of Compilation, Revision and Publication of Laws and Regulations, (Volumes 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 11), 2013, 2014, 2015. (in Persian)
    • Mohebi, Mohsen, translator: Mohammad Habibi Majandeh, The Iran-United States Claims Tribunal (nature, structure, function), Tehran: Fardafar, 2013. (in Persian)
    • Movahed, Mohammad Ali, Lessons from Oil Arbitrations, first volume, first edition, Tehran: International Legal Services Office, 1995. (in Persian)
    • Mousazadeh, Reza, Principles of Public International Law, 3rd edition, Tehran: Mizan, 2013. (in Persian)
    • Rawls, Rudolph and Christophe Schroer, translator: Sayyed Ghasem Zamani and Behazin Hasibi, Principles of International Investment Law, 3rd edition, Tehran: Shahrdanesh Institute of Legal Studies and Research, 2015. (in Persian)
    • Safai, Sayyed Hossein, International Law and International Arbitrations, first edition, Tehran: Mizan, 1996. (in Persian)
    • Yannaca-Small, Katia, Fair and Equitable Treatment Standard: Recent Developments, Oxford University Press, (2008), (in English)

    Articles:

    • Adel, Morteza; "Rules of Fairness in the Common Law System", Law Quarterly, 1 (2010). (in Persian)
    • Ahangari, Behzad; "Fairness in Foreign Investment Arbitration Documents and Procedures", Treaty Legal Research, 3 (2017). (in Persian)
    • Alidosti Shahraki, Nasser; "Fairness in Settlement of Foreign Investment Disputes", Law Quarterly (Journal of School of Law and Political Science), 3(2010). (in Persian)
    • Amini, Azam; " Rethinking the Inter-relationship of Law and Equity ", Private Law Research Quarterly, 16 (2015). (in Persian)
    • Baya, Fadhlurrahman, Hula, Adolf, Prita, Amalia;"Lemiting Investor Legitimate Expectations In Foreign Investment To Ensure State Economic Sovereignty"; International Journal of Business Economic and Law; 23 (2020), (in English)
    • Bitar, Khalil, "A Social Equity Assessment Tool (SEAT) For Evaluation", Willy Brandt School of Public Policy, University of Erfurt, (2021), (in English)
    • Mafi, Homayoun; "An analysis of the performance of the Iran-United States Claims Tribunal ", Journal of Law and Politics Research, 24 (2007). (in Persian)
    • Mafi, Homayoun, Zahra Mahmoudi Kordi and Ali Qahari; "Fair Measures in the Procedure of the Iran-United States Claims Tribunal ", Legal Research Quarterly, 92 (2019). (in Persian)
    • Mirfakhrai, Sayyed Hasan, Sadegh Piri; " Study on Applicability of Amity Treaty of 1955 for Propounding the Case in the ICJ in Regard to the Western Sanctions against Iran"; International Relations Studies Quarterly; ninth year; number 34; (2015). (in Persian)
    • Mohebi, Mohsen; "Regime of the Applicable law of Iran-United States Claims Tribunal in oil Disputes and its Effect on the International Arbitration Process", Legal Research Journal, 27-28 (1999). (in Persian)
    • Motiei, Ensieh and Masoud Alborzi Varki; "Comparative Study of the Principle of Fairness and the Principles of Justice and Fairness", Comparative Law Research, 3 (2017). (in Persian)
    • Pasban, Mohammadreza and Zainab Asghari; " The Role of Fair and Equitable Treatment in the Settlement of Foreign Investment Disputes: With Particular Emphasis on Social Responsibility of Transnational Corporations ", Private Law Research Quarterly, 8 (2013). (in Persian)
    • POPA(TACHE), Cristina Elena, "International Investment Protection in front of the States Role in Crisis Times to Managing Disputes", Judicial Tribune, 10 (2020). (in English)
    • Schreuer, Christoph, "Fair and Equitable Treatment in Arbital Practice", The Journal of World Investment and Trade, 6(2005), (in English)
    • Shiravi, Abdul Hossein; "The Theory of Unfairness and Unconscionability of Contractual Terms in Common Law with Emphasis on the Laws of England, America, and Australia"; Qom Higher Education Complex Magazine, 14 (2002). (in Persian)

    Document:

    Draft Covention on the Protection of Foreign Property and Resolution of the Council of the OECD on the Draft Convention, (1967). (in English)