Journal of Legal Research

Journal of Legal Research

The Necessity to Observe the Interests of the company in the Assumption of Director’s Contract with Himself with Recognition in the British Legal System

Document Type : Original Article

Author
Assistant Professor, Department of Jurisprudence and Islamic Law, Faculty of Humanities, Bozorgmehr University of Qaenat, Qain, Iran.
Abstract
The manager's transaction on behalf of the company with himself is a situation of conflict of interest and is possible that the manager considers his own interests to be preferable to the interests of it; Accordingly, the legislator should try to protect the company. The legislator has issued a ruling only in relation to a joint-stock company what he means is the place of dispute; Therefore, the purpose is to deduce the legislator's opinions regarding the mentioned company and others in comparison with English law. In the above company, managers must first take the consent of the board of directors and then the general meeting of co-partners (Article 129 of the Amendment bill of the commercial code). Otherwise, the transaction can be canceled; even if invalidity conflicts with third-party rights with good intentions (Article 131 of the mentioned code); However, if the consent of the board of directors has been obtained and the assembly does not approve, and the invalidity of the transaction conflicts with the third party, the transaction will be valid with respect to him (Article 130 of the above code). In other companies, according to the similarity, the same rulings should be valid; As for the cooperative society, the rules of the joint stock company are current; but sometimes, it is not possible; Therefore, the rules of agency must be enforced. In the British, the above transaction is also accepted; But it has differences with Iran; Such as all companies are subject to uniform rules.
Keywords

  • Ameli, Javad. Meftaholkerame, Volume 12 and 21, Qom, office of Islamic publications depended to teacher society of scientific assembly of Qom, (1998), (in Arabic).
  • Ameli, Yasin. idiomof Juristic in practical messages, (1nded), Beirut: Dar Al-Balagha for Printing, Publishing and Distribution, (1992), (in Arabic).
  • Ansari, Morteza. Makaseb, Volume 3, Qom, World Congress in honor of Sheikh Azam Ansari, (1995), (in Arabic).
  • Asghari Aqhamshahdi, Fakhruddin and Mohammad Isa Tafarshi. "The legal nature of the relationship between managers of joint-stock companies and the company", Journal of the Faculty of Administrative Sciences and Economics of the University of Isfahan, 2(2005), 35-52, (in Persian).
  • Asgari Tovani, Ali. "The legal nature of the manager's relationship with commercial companies", Judicial Monthly, 47 (1383), 77-81, (in Persian).
  • Abdullahi Nejad, Abdul Karim, Mohammad Hassan Rabbani and Gurban Jalal. " Orders Subjection to Benefits and Corruptions", Scientific Research The knowledge Studies in the Islamic University, Volume 20, Issue 68 - Serial Number 68, (2016), Pages 359-374. (in Persian).
  • Alavi, Sayyed Mohmmad Taqhi; Seyedeh mahshid Miri balajorshari ,The Destinations of Religion and the Role and Place of Expediency in Legislation, Jurisprudence and Criminal Law Doctrines,Volume 1, Issue 3 - Serial Number 3, (2022), Pages 65-78, (in Persian).
  • Aberdeen Railway Co v Blaikie Brothers co.uk/aberdeen-railway-co-v-blaikie-brothers-hl-1854/ accessed in june 20, (2018), (in English).
  • Bahrani, Yusef., hadaueqolnazere, Volume 18, (1nded), Qom: office of Islamic publications associated to assembly of professors of howze Qom, (1984), (in Arabic).
  • Bahrol Ulom, Mohamad., Balghat Ol Faqih, Volume 3, (4nded), Tehran: Maktabet Ol Sadiq publications, (1982), (in Arabic).
  • Behbahani, Mohamad Bagher, Practical Treatise Mtajr Vahid Behbahani (with Description of Mirza Shirazi),(1nded), Tehran: Sheikh Reza Tehrani, (1899), (in Arabic).
  • Bariklu, Ali Reza. Transaction outside the jurisdiction of the director, Legal ideas, second year, number 6, (2004), 35- 52.
  • Campbell, Joseph Charles. "Fiduciary Relationships in a Commercial Context", Sydney Law School Research Paper, No. 14/26, (2014), 1- 69, (in English).
  • Emami, Hasan. civil law, Volume 5, Tehran, Islamieh publications, (1992), (in Persian)
  • Frahidi, KH, The Book of AlEyn, Volume 4, (2nded), Qom: Hijr Publishing, (1990), (in Arabic).
  • Fiumi, Ahmad. The bright lamp in Gharib, the great explanation of Rafii, volume 2, (1nded), Qom: Dar Al-Ridhi publications, (No date), (in Arabic).
  • Ghahremani, Nasrallah. "The legal nature of brokerage in business law". Lawyers' Association, 184 and 185(2013), 72-88, (in Persian).
  • Helli, Hasan. QavaedolAhkam, volume 2, Qom, office of Islamic publications associated to assembly of professors of howze Qom, (1993), (in Arabic).
  • Helli, Hasan. Mokhtalef ol Shieh, Volume 5 and 6, (2nded), Qom: office of Islamic publications associated to assembly of professors of howze Qom, (1992), (in Arabic).
  • Helli, Hasan. Ershad ol Azhan, volume 1, (1nded), Qom: office of Islamic publications associated to assembly of professors of howze Qom, (1999), (in Arabic).
  • Helli, Ibn Edris. Sraer, volume 1, (2nded), Qom: office of Islamic publications associated to assembly of professors of howze Qom, (1999), (in Arabic).
  • Hur Ameli, Mohamad. Vasaelol Shiah, volume 17, (1nded), Qom: Institute of Aholbeit peace be upon them, (1988), (in Arabic).
  • Isfahani, Hoseyn, Mufradat al-Faz al-Quran, (1nded), Lebanon-Syria: Dar Al- elm - Dar Al-Shamia, (1992), (in Arabic).
  • Ibn Manzoor, Abolfazl, Arabic language, volume 7, (3nded), Beirut: Dar Al-Fikr for printing, publishing and distribution - Dar Sader, (1993), (in Arabic).
  • Jouhari, Ismail, al-Sahah-Taj al-Laghhi and Sahah al-Arabi, Volume 3, (1nded), Beirut: Dar al-Alam Lalmaylain, (1990), (in Arabic).
  • Jafari langrudi, Mohamad Jaffar, extended law terminology, Volume 2 and 4, (3nded), Tehran, Ganje danesh, . (2007), (in Persian).
  • Karaki, Ali. Jamealmaqased, volume 8, (1nded), Qom: institute of ahololbeyt peace be upon them, (1993), (in Arabic).
  • Khatoziyan, Naser. General Principles of Contracts, volume 2, (6nded), Tehran: stock co of publications with collaboration of Bahman Borna, (2004), (in Persian).
  • Khuyi, Abolghasem. Misbah ol fqahh, (No date), No Place, (in Arabic).
  • MohAqeq Helli, najmoldin. Sharaye Islam, volume 2, Qom, Institute of Ismailiyan, (1987), (in Arabic).
  • Musavi Khomeyni, Ruhollah. Tahrir ol vasile, volume 2, Qom, Dar ol Elem, (No date), (in Arabic).
  • Martin, Elizabeth A. Dictionary of law, Fifth edition, Oxford: university press, 1384, (in English).
  • Moqaddas Ardebili, Ahmad. majmaolfaede, volume 4, (1nded), Qom: office of Islamic publications depended to teacher society of scientific assembly of Qom, (1992), (in Arabic).
  • Mostafavi, Hasan. Research the words of the Holy Quran, volume 6, (1nded), Tehran: Book Center for Translation and Publishing, (1982), (in Arabic).
  • Mohammadi, Sam and Ali Bagheri, AN INVESTIGATION OF THE STATUS AND EFFECTS OF THE CEO’S CONTRACT WITH THE COMPANY COMPARE WITH THE NEW BILL OF BUSINESS LAW, Private Law Studies Quarterly, Volume 45, Issue 2 - Serial Number 2, (2015), Pages 339-359, (in Persian).
  • Najafi, Mohamad Hasan, Javaherol Kalam fi sharh sharaye Islam, volume 27, (7nded), Beirut: Dar ol Ehya al Toras al Arabi, (1983), (in Arabic).
  • Nosworthy, Beth. "Directors’ fiduciary obligations: Is the shareholder an appropriate beneficiary?", Australian Journal of Corporate Law, No. 3, (2010), 282- 307, (in English).
  • Niknezhad, javad. Lawful Status of Directors in Stocks Companies of Iran & England Jurisprudence & Law, Volume 7, Issue 25, (2011), 169-200, (in Persian).
  • Pasban, Mohamad Reza, Business Law, (3nded), Tehran:samt, (2009), (in Persian).
  • Pasban, Mohamad Reza and javad Niknejad, The Legal Position of Managers in Joint Stock Companies, Journal of Free Legal Research. Volume 4, Issue 14, (2011), pp. 40-9, (in Persian).
  • Qomi, AbolGhasem. Jameah Shatat, volume 2 and 4, (1nded), Tehran: Keyhan Institute, (1992), (in Arabic).
  • Radan, Peter, Stewart, Cameron, Principles of Australian Equity and Trusts, Chatswood: LexisNexis, (2010), (in English)
  • Shahid Aval. Mohamad. Al- Dorus,Volume 3, (2nded), Qom: office of Islamic publications depended to teacher society of scientific assembly of Qom, (2006), (in Arabic).
  • Shahid sani. Zeyondin. Al- Razat Al- Bahiyah, Volume 4, (1nded), Qom: Davari Bookstore, (1989), (in Arabic).
  • Shahid sani, Zeyondin. masalekolafham, Volume 3 and 5, (1nded), Qom: institute of Islamic knowledges, (1992), (in Arabic).
  • Saduq, Mohamad, Man La Yazrah Al-Ufiyyah - Translated, Ghaffari, Ali Akbar, Volume 4, (1nded), Tehran: Sadough Publishing, (1989), (in Arabic).
  • Sotoudeh Tehrani, Hassan. Business Law, Vol. 2, Ch. 6, Tehran: Nash Dadgstar, (2006), (in Persian).
  • Stuart, Sime and Margot Taylor. Company law in practice, Tenth edition, Oxford: university press, (2014), (in English).
  • Smith, Gordon. "The Critical Resource Theory of Fiduciary duty", Vanderbilt Law Review, 5, (2002), 1399- 1497. (in English).
  • Skini, Rabia. TradingCorporations, Volume 2, (7nded), Tehran: Samt, (2004), (in Persian).
  • Shiravi, Abdolhoseyn. comparative law, (2nded), Tehran: Samt, (2005), (in Persian).
  • Toussi, abujafar. Almbsout, Volume 2, Tehran, Maktabah Mortezaviyah, (1968), (in Arabic).
  • Tousi, abujafar. Alkhalaf, Volume 3, Qom, office of Islamic publications associated to assembly of professors of howze Qom, (1988), (in Arabic).
  • Tabatabaei Yazdi, Mohamadkazem. Takmele Orvatol Vosqa, Volume 1, (1nded), Qom: Davari Bookstore, (1993), (in Arabic).
  • Tarihi, Fakhrodin, Bahrain Assembly, Volume 2, (3nded), Tehran: Mortazavi Bookstore, (1995), (in Arabic).
  • Tabatabaei, Mohamadhoseyn. Translated by al-Mizan, Translated by Mohammad Bagher Mousavi, Volume 4 and 9, (2nded), Qom: Teachers' Association of The Seminary of Qom, Islamic Publications Office, (1996), (in Persian).
  • Williamson, Oliver E. The Economic Institutions of Capitalism Firms, Markets, Relational Contracting, newyork: Free Press, (1985), (in English).