Two people sign a contract with each other in Isfahan and the place of fulfillment of the commitment is Tehran. The first party files a lawsuit against the defendant in Tehran once, and the verdict is issued against him. He brings the same lawsuit without changing the legal reason in Isfahan for the second time. The defendant is not informed about the new lawsuit, or he does not go to court to defend himself, thinking that the court will again issue a verdict in his favor. The verdict, however, will be issued in favor of the plaintiff. According to the Civil Procedure Law, if two judgments are contradictory with the same subject, cause and, parties, the second judgment will have the possibility of retrial. By interpreting "the same court" as "unity in the branch" or "unity in the jurisdiction" which is accepted by the doctrine and judicial procedure, the reinstatement of proceedings is eliminated. In this article, the above viewpoints are criticized and with a comparative study and a review of the former civil procedure laws, the view of the unity of class and type is accepted.
Eftekhar Jahromi, Godarz, Mostafa Alsan. “Civil Code of Procedure”. Mizan Publication, Volume 2, 2020: 304 (in Persian)
Hayati, Abbas. ”Civil Code of Procedure in Current Legal Order”. Mizan Publication, 2011: 674-675 (in Persian)
Judiciary Press and Publishing Center. “Judicial Background Related to Civil Code of Procedure”. The Judiciary Publication, Volume 2, 2018: 347-348 (in Persian)
Karimi, Abbas, Hamidreza Parto. “Civil Code of Procedure”. Dadgostar Publication, Volume 2, 2019: 201 (in Persian)
Madani, Jalaleddin. “Civil Code of Procedure”. Ganje Danesh Publication, Volume 2, 1996: 552-574 (in Persian)
Matin Daftari, Ahmad. “Civil and Business Code of Procedure”. Majd Publication, Volume 2, 2009: 172, 432 (in Persian)
Sadrzadeh Afshar, Mohsen. “Civil and Business Code of Procedure”. Jahad Daneshgahi Publication, 2011: 298 (in Persian)
Shams, Abdollah. ”Civil Code of Procedure”. Derak Publication, Volume 2, 2019: 434-436 (in Persian)
Shams, Abdollah. ”Civil Code of Procedure”. Derak Publication, Volume 1, 2019: 452 (in Persian)
Vahedi, Ghodratollah, Civil Code of Procedure”. Majd Publication, Volume 2, 2014: 173 (in Persian)
Zeraat, Abbas. “Civil Code of Procedure”. Daneshpazir Publication, 2019: 336 (in Persian)
Articles
Hasanzadeh, Mahdi.” A comparative study of the Causes of appealing to the Supreme Court in Iranian and French law”. Mofidi Journal, no. 94, (February 2013): 65 (in Persian)
Hasanzadeh, Mahdi.” A comparative study of the Causes of retrial in Iranian and French law”. Comparative Law Journal 15, no. 4, (February 2012): 2 (in Persian)
Hayati,Abbas. “A critical analysis of the aspects of "retrial of proceedings" in Iran's Civil Code of Procedure with a comparative study in French law, Critical Study 18, no.5 (August 2018): 196 (in Persian)
Karimi, Ali Asghar. “The Necessity of Removal of Restrictions from the appealing-to-the-supreme-court stage in the civil code of procedure”. Legal visions Journal, no.54, (June 2012): 6 (in Persian)
Parvin, Kheirollah. “Review of the legal system of Lebanon”. Constitutional Law Journal, no. 8, (March 2007): 76 (in Persian)
Thesis
Abbasi, Javad. “Retrial in Legal”, MA thesis, (2001): 156 (in Persian)
Kamran, Mirhaji. “Retrial in Iran Law”. MA thesis, (2007): 24(in Persian)
Taherifard,R. (2024). Examining the Retrial for Conflicting Two Rulings Emphasizing the "Same Court" Element in the Light of Doctrine and Judicial Procedure. Journal of Legal Research, 23(59), 405-426. doi: 10.48300/jlr.2023.375682.2231
MLA
Taherifard,R. . "Examining the Retrial for Conflicting Two Rulings Emphasizing the "Same Court" Element in the Light of Doctrine and Judicial Procedure", Journal of Legal Research, 23, 59, 2024, 405-426. doi: 10.48300/jlr.2023.375682.2231
HARVARD
Taherifard R. (2024). 'Examining the Retrial for Conflicting Two Rulings Emphasizing the "Same Court" Element in the Light of Doctrine and Judicial Procedure', Journal of Legal Research, 23(59), pp. 405-426. doi: 10.48300/jlr.2023.375682.2231
CHICAGO
R. Taherifard, "Examining the Retrial for Conflicting Two Rulings Emphasizing the "Same Court" Element in the Light of Doctrine and Judicial Procedure," Journal of Legal Research, 23 59 (2024): 405-426, doi: 10.48300/jlr.2023.375682.2231
VANCOUVER
Taherifard R. Examining the Retrial for Conflicting Two Rulings Emphasizing the "Same Court" Element in the Light of Doctrine and Judicial Procedure. Journal of Legal Research, 2024; 23(59): 405-426. doi: 10.48300/jlr.2023.375682.2231
