Journal of Legal Research

Journal of Legal Research

Study of Dispossession Lawsuit about Joint Property Based on the Resolution of Judicial Ambiguity

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD Student in Private Law, Faculty of Law, Damghan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Damghan, Iran.
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Private Law, Faculty of Law, Damghan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Damghan, Iran.
3 Assistant Professor, Department of Private Law, Faculty of Law, Shahrood Branch, Islamic Azad University, Shahrood, Iran.
Abstract
One of the involved issues in precedent for Deficiency of the rules is dispossession lawsuit aboat Joint property. This lawsuit is subject to Special rules as such recognition and Solving Its ambiguities realizes Justly trial. So we started writing this article and The consequence was that in Judicial process; Judges do not have certain criterion for cognizance the ownership of the claimant and recognition the defendant in this lawsuit; Also, at the time of death or disability or change of one of the claimants or multiple defendants, they are confused; And in the stage of enforcement of judgments, these ambiguities were more be revealed So that How to deliver and manage the joint property and determine the standing property have serious ambiguity. In order to resolve these ambiguities; We hang on Article 43 of the Civil judgments enforcement Act and General Assembly of the Supreme Court vote No. 672 and Its defects were solved with Acceptance of two principles “The result of the dispossession lawsuit aboat Joint property transmits to all owners” and “Resolving disputes between partners depends on permission”.
Keywords

  • Abazari Fumshi, Mansour. " Civil judgments enforcement Act in the current legal system". First Edition. Tehran: Khorsandi Publications, 2016. (in persian)
  • Iftikhar Jahormi, Gouders and Mojtaba Shafii. "Legal status of joint  property lease". Private Law Research Quarterly 33(2019): 39-61. (in persian)
  • Emami, Seyyed Hassan. Civil laws. The second volume. Edition 30. Tehran: Islamia Publications, 2019. (in persian)
  • Bashiri, Abbas. Application rights of lands and estates registration. second edition. Tehran: Javadane Publications, 2019. (in persian)
  • Bayat, Farhad and Shirin Bayat. Comprehensive description of civil law. 19th edition Tehran: Arshad Publications, 2019. (in persian)
  • Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jaafar. Description of law terminology. First Edition. Tehran: Ganj Danesh Publications, 1999. (in persian)
  • Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jaafar. Legal terminology. fourth edition. Tehran: Ganj Danesh Publications, 1989. (in persian)
  • Hosseini, Rooh Elah. "Effects of interest division and partner possession in joint property". New Research in Human Sciences 33(2021):343-358. (in persian)
  • Khodabakhshi, Abdullah. litigations rights (general rules of litigations). First Edition. Tehran: Athakh Publishing Company, 2012. (in persian)
  • Khodabakhshi, Abdullah. Rights governing the Civil judgments enforcement. First Edition. Tehran: Publishing Company, 2014. (in persian)
  • Khodabakhshi, Abdullah. "Legal Analysis of action to quiet title", Journal of Legals Researches 14(2008):291-333. (in persian)
  • Zinali, Mehdi. dispossession lawsuit in court procedure. Third edition. Tehran: Chirag Danesh Publications, 2016. (in persian)
  • Sohrabi, Yasser. Brief application of the general rules of contracts. second edition. Tehran: Publications of the Center of Press and Publications of the Judiciary, 2021. (in persian)
  • Shafii, Hossein. Methods and solutions Civil judgments enforcement (scientific and practical). Sixth edition. Qom: dynamic Law Publications, 2021. (in persian)
  • Shams, Abdullah. civil procedure rules, fundamental period. The first volume. Eighth edition. Tehran: Drak Publications, 2009. (in persian)
  • Shams, Abdullah. civil procedure rules, fundamental period. The secand volume. Eighth edition. Tehran: Drak Publications, 2009. (in persian)
  • Shams, Abdullah. civil procedure rules , Advanced period. first volume. Twenty-fifth edition. Tehran: Drak Publications, 2019. (in persian)
  • Shams, Abdullah. civil procedure rules , Advanced period. Secand   sixty-fifth edition. Tehran: Drak Publications, 2019. (in persian)
  • Shams, Abdullah Civil judgments enforcement, method of implementation. The second volume. Third edition. Tehran: Drak Publications, 2018. (in persian)
  • Shams, Abdullah. Civil judgments enforcement, general rules. The first volume. Third edition. Tehran: Drak Publications, 2018. (in persian)
  • Shahidi, Mehdi. Civil laws, special contracts. fourth edition. Tehran: Majd Publications, 2005. (in persian)
  • Sadeghi Goldar, Ahmed. " Partnership Contract, concept and its territory". Legal and judicial studies 9(1987):177-189. (in persian)
  • Samadi, Mahmoud. "Examination of the conditions and effects of dispossession lawsuit aboat Joint property with an emphasis on Article 43 of the Civil judgments enforcement Act", Thesis for Master's degree, Shahrood: Faculty of Law, Islamic Azad University, Shahrood branch, 2014. (in persian)
  • Ebadi Bashir, Maqsood. "Rent of joint property". Kanon Monthly 88(2008): 70-92. (in persian)
  • Faqihi Nejad, Mehdi and Samieh Babaiian Ferdavi. " action to quiet title and dispossession lawsuit in different stages of registration in Iran's judicial procedure". Judicial Law Journal 70(2010): 68-33. (in persian)
  • Katouzian, Nasser. Civil rights, special contracts, partnerships, cinclusion of peace. The second volume. Ninth edition. Tehran: Ganj Danesh Library Publications, 2013.
  • Katouzian, Nasser. Property and ownership. Fifty-sixth edition. Tehran: Mezan Publishing House, 2021. (in persian)
  • Katouzian, Nasser. General rules of contracts. Volume III. The seventh edition. Tehran: Publishing Company, 2012. (in persian)
  • Kazemnejad Sangrudi, Hassan. "Differentiation and commonality of dispossession lawsuits and ejectment". Scientific Journal of Jurisprudence, Law and Criminal Sciences 9(2017): 123-131. (in persian)
  • Kazemi, Mahmoud. " dispossession lawsuit, conflict of official and ordinary deed, review of the written judement number 9709972993700410 of the second branch of the legal court of Roudbar district of Qasran, Tehran". Journal of Judgment 100(2018): 1-41. (in persian)
  • Kamalzadeh, Mohammad. " dispossession lawsuit and its related rules with an attitude towards judicial procedure". Dissertation for Master's Degree, Mashhad: Faculty of Administrative and Economic Sciences, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, 2014. (in persian)
  • Muhadesi, Maeda. "Comparison of dispossession lawsuit and quit premises in terms of substance". Journal of the Association of Lawyers 211(2010): 29-64. (in persian)
  • The center for the extraction and studies of the judicial procedure of the country. The collection of judicial opinions of the Courts of Appeal of Tehran province (legal) Mehr 2011. First edition. Tehran: Judiciary Press and Publishing Center, 2014. (in persian)
  • Moin, Mohammad. Persian Dictionary, Third edition. Tehran: Moin Publications, 2007. (in persian)
  • Mousavi, Mahmoud. "study of the dispossession lawsuit aboat Joint property ". Journal of Jurisprudence, Law and Criminal Sciences 6(2016): 70-76. (in persian)
  • Mousavi Moghadam, Mohammad. Analysis and criticism of the judicial procedure, dispossession lawsuit. second edition. Qom: Today's Rights Publications, 2018. (in persian)
  • Mohajeri, Ali. Encyclopaedia of Civil judgments enforcement. first volume. First Edition. Tehran: Fekrsazan Publishing House, 2016. (in persian)
  • Hadi, Hamed. ejectment in Iran's civil procedure law with a comparative study in Imami jurisprudence and French law. First Edition. Tehran: Imam Sadegh University Press, 2018. (in persian)