Journal of Legal Research

Journal of Legal Research

The Latest Developments in the Crime of Aggression in International Law

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
Mohsen Ghadir 1
Mohamdreza Rashnavadi 2
1 Assistant Professor, Department of International Law, Faculty of Law, University of Qom, Qom, Iran.
2 PhD Student in International Law, Faculty of Law, Qom University, Qom, Iran.
10.48300/jlr.2023.395871.2340
Abstract
The crime of territorial aggression is among the most terrible international crimes. After the outbreak of World War II, the Allies decided to try the defeated Axis of this war, including on charges of crimes against peace. After seventy years since the last and only case of the crime of aggression was prosecuted in an international criminal court, the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court was activated in July 2018 over the crime of aggression. The explanation of the way to activate the jurisdiction of the court and its fruition since the drafting of the statute followed a winding path and lasted for two decades. The 16th session of the General Assembly of the International Court of Justice started on the 4th of December at the headquarters of the United Nations in New York with the speech of the Secretary General of the United Nations and ended on the 14th of December. The most important achievement of the 16th summit was the activation of the International Criminal Court's jurisdiction over the crime of "Territorial aggression". we seek to investigate the latest developments in the crime of aggression in international law using a descriptive-analytical method.
Keywords
Crime of Aggression
International Criminal Court
Activation of the Jurisdiction of the Court
International Law
Kampala Conference
  • Abangah, Mohammad. Mahdavi saabet, Mohammad Ali. Ashuri, Mohammad, Ardabili, Mohammad Ali. "The mutual influence of the opinions of national criminal courts and international criminal courts in the light of the rule of prohibition of retrial and re-punishment", Quarterly Journal of Public Law Studies, 49(3)(2019). (in Persian).
  •   Pourbafarani, Hassan. "Jurisdiction of domestic courts in dealing with the crime of territorial aggression", Research Journal of Criminal Law 8(2) (2017). (in Persian).
  •    Zaker Hossein, Mohammad Hadi. "Achievements of the 16th session of the International Criminal Court Member States Assembly", Iranian Diplomacy News Base/Azar 28, (2017). (in Persian).
  •   Salimi, Sadegh. "Limitations of the International Criminal Court in exercising jurisdiction over the perpetrators of the crime of aggression", Public Law Research 22(69) (2020). (in Persian).
  •   Soodmandi, Abdul Majid. "Dealing with the crime of aggression in the International Criminal Court", Tehran: Negah Baeineh, (2015). (in Persian).
  •   Mazaheri, Amir Masoud. Principle of Supplementary Jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court, first edition, Mizan, Tehran, Winter, (2012). (in Persian).
  •   Najhndi Manesh. Haibatollah. Bazar, Vahid. "Complementarity of the International Criminal Court's Jurisdiction and the Crime of Aggression", Criminal Law Doctrines 14(2017). (in Persian).
  • Akande, Dapo. “What Exactly Was Agreed in Kampala on the Crime of Aggression?”, EQ: Equality of Arms Review, A Publication of the International Bar Association’s ICC Monitoring and Outreach Program, Volume 2, Issue 2, November )2010(, available at: ibanet.org/documents/Default.aspx. (in English)
  • Akande, Dapo, Antanios Tzanakopoulos. “Treaty Law and ICC Jurisdiction over the Crime of Aggression”, European Journal of International Law, Vol. 29, Issue 3, (2018), https:// doi. org/ 10.1093/ejil/chy059. (in English)
  • Ambos, Kai. “The Crime of Aggression After Kampala”. In German Yearbook of International Law;(2010), Vol. 53, pp. 463-509. (in English)
  • Cassel, Douglass. “Pursuing Peace with Justice: Lessons from Uganda”, Worldview Commentary, 247, (2008), available at: http:// www. chicagopublicradio. org/ content. aspx? audioID= 669. (in English)
  • CORTEN, Olivier, and Vaios KOUTROULIS. "Tribunal for the crime of aggression against Ukraine-a legal assessment." (2022).‏ (in English)
  • Clark, Phil, If Ocampo Indicts Bashir. “Nothing May Happen” (Oxford Transitional Justice ResearchGroup),(2008)available at: http://www.csls.ox.ac.uk/documents/Clark_Final.pdf. (in English)
  • Claus Kre and Leonie von Holtzendorff. “The Kampala Compromise on the Crime of Aggression”, Journal of International Criminal Justice (8), (2010). (in English)
  • Derbal, Ayad. “The ICC’s Involvement in the Situation in Darfur: Not a Threat to Peace”, University of Notre Dame, Centre for Civil and Human Rights, Working Paper No.1 Winter (2008). (in English)
  • EQ: Equality of Arms Review, “A Publication of the International Bar Association’s ICC Monitoring and Outreach Program”, Volume 2, Issue 2, November (2010), available at: org/ documents/Default.aspx. (in English)
  • Galea, Ion, “Interpretation of the Kampala Amendments -One of the Key Issues for Activating the Jurisdiction of the ICC over the Crime of Aggression”, Journal of Law and Administrative Sciences. 175, (2017). (in English)
  • Jocelyn Getgen Kestenbaum. “Closing Impunity Gaps for the Crime of Aggression”, 17 J. Int'l L. 51, (2016). (in English)
  • Kreß, Claus. "On the Activation of ICC Jurisdiction over the Crime of Aggression." The Rome Statute of the ICC at Its Twentieth Anniversary. Brill Nijhoff,. 43-64.‏ (2018). (in English)
  • Kevin Jon Heller. Retreat from Nuremberg: “The Leadership Requirement in the Crime of Aggression”, The European Journal of International Law, Vol.18, (2007). (in English)
  • Londras, Fiona. “The Crime of Aggression at the ICC Review Conference”, available at: http:// www. humanrights. ie/ index. php/2010/06/13/the-crime-of-aggression-at-the-icc-review-conference/, last visited 23Dec. (2010). (in English)
  • Quintana, Juan Jose. “A Note on the Activation of the ICC's Jurisdiction over the Crime of Aggression”, The Law & Practice of International Courts and Tribunals, Vol. 17, Issue 1, (2018). (in English)
  • Report on the facilitation on the activation of the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court over the crime of aggression, // available at: ICC-ASP/16/24, (2017). (in English)
  • Ruys, Tom. “Criminalizing Aggression: How the Future of the Law on the Use of Force Rests in the Hands of the ICC”. European Journal of International Law (Forthcoming), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2964731, (2017). (in English)
  • Salari, Asma, and Seyed Hossein Hosseini. "Russia's Attack on Ukraine: A Review of the International Criminal Court's Capacity to Examine the Crime of Aggression." Access to Just. E. Eur.(2023): 8. (in English)
  • Schurech, Res. “The International Criminal Court at the Mercy of Powerful States; An Assessment of the Neo-Colonialism Claim Made by African Stakeholders”, ASSER PRESS, International Criminal Justice Series, Vol. 13, (2017). (in English)
  • Smith, Lorraine. “What did the ICC Review Conference achieve?” EQ: Equality of Arms Review, A publication of the International Bar Association’s ICC Monitoring and Outreach Program, Volume 2, Issue 2, November (2010), available at: ibanet. org/ documents/Default.aspx. (in English)
  • Song, Judge Sang-Hyun, “Reflections on the ICC Review Conference: Perspectives of the ICC President”, EQ: Equality of Arms Review, A publication of the International Bar Association’s ICC Monitoring and Outreach Program, Volume 2, Issue 2, November (2010), available at: ibanet.org/documents/Default.aspx. (in English)
  • Sterio, Milena. "The Ukraine Crisis and the Future of International Courts and Tribunals." Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law1 (2023): 479.‏ (in English)
  • Trahan, Jennifer, “Jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court over the Crime of Aggression”, International Criminal Law Review, Vol. 18, No. 2, (2018). (in English)
  • Trahan, Jennifer. "The Need for an International Tribunal on the Crime of Aggression Regarding the Situation in Ukraine." Fordham International Law Journal5 (2023): 629. (in English)
  • Zimmermann, Andreas. "Amending the amendment provisions of the Rome Statute: the Kampala compromise on the crime of aggression and the law of treaties." Journal of international criminal justice1 (2012): 209-227.‏. (in English)
  • Doc.A/65/313,2010, Report of the International Criminal Court to the United Nations for 2009/10. (in English).
  • African Union, Peace and Security Council (New York, 2008) available at: http:// www. african-union, org/ root/ au/ Conferences/2008/July/psc/Sudan%20Comm%20(Eng).pdf. (in English).
  • http://treaties.un.org.Reference: C.N.651.2010.TREATIES-8
  • Resolution RC/Res.6 of the Review Conference of the Rome Statute.2017.
  • icc-cpi.int/iccdocs/other/2015_NV_Kenya_Declaration_article15bis-4.pdf
Journal of Legal Research
Volume 23, Issue 59
Autumn 2024
Pages 37-68