Journal of Legal Research

Journal of Legal Research

The Rule of Immunity of the State with Emphasis on the Approach of the Russian Federation

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD Student in International Law, Faculty of Law, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
2 Assistant Professor, Department of International Law, Faculty of Law, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
The maintenance of the sovereign equality of states rests largely on the adherence to the law of state immunity and its imperative respect. This fundamental principle finds acceptance in international documents, customary international law, and international judicial practice. Recognizing its importance, some governments have found it necessary to codify rules pertaining to state immunity within their domestic legal systems, thereby establishing it as an independent law. Russia, following the adoption of the 2004 UN Convention, enacted regulations on state immunity, effective from 2016. However, the Ukraine crisis, coupled with Russia's military invasion, and the subsequent seizure of Russian assets abroad, as well as the stance of Russia and other governments regarding this crisis, has posed a new challenge in the area of state immunity. By examining Russia's approach to this principle within its own legal framework, and scrutinizing the extent of its commitment to the principle and its exceptions, we can ascertain how Russia engages with foreign governments and evaluate the likelihood of foreign governments seizing and detaining Russian assets beyond its borders. Notwithstanding the fact that certain assets belonging to Russia and its central bank have been seized, they have not yet been confiscated or forfeited due to the legal barrier of state immunity. To date, many governments have been unable to furnish the necessary legal permits and documentation to take action against these assets.
 
Keywords

-Abdolahi, Mohsen & Shafe, Mirshahbiz. "State Immunity in International Law", Second Edition, Tehran: Publishers Vice President of Research, Compilation and Revision of Presidential Laws and Regulations (2007) (in Persian) -Abdolahi, Seyed Mohammad Ali & Habib Zadeh, Tavakol. "A comparative study of government immunity, the doctrine of government action and the jurisdiction of domestic courts". Second Edition, Tehran: Publications of the Judiciary Research Institute (2021) (in Persian)
-Afrasiaban, Vahid. "The trio of the United States, Russia and Ukraine in the structure of the international system in 2022". International Journal of Nations Research, Volume: 7 Issue: 75 (2022): 99-116 (in Persian)
-Aliyev, Azar- Bessonova, Anastasiia, Russian Law on Immunities: First Stock- Taking, 2020 (in English) 
-Ansari Moein, Parviz. "State Immunity and their Property with Seventeen Appendices of Related Documents". First Edition, Tehran: Publishers Mizan. (2010) (in Persian)
-Bahrani, Abdul Samad & Salahi, Sohrab & Diyanat, Mohsen. "Immunity of state property in international law Looking at the seizure of Iranian oil exports by the United States". International Legal Research. 15(55) (2022):149-171 (in Persian)
-Bozorgmehri, Majid. "History of International Relations (1870- 1945)". Second Edition, Tehran: Organization of study and editing of university humanities books (Samt), (2006) (in Persian)
-Daneshnia, Farhad & Marabi, Mehri. "The Constructivist Confrontation of Russia and USA in Ukraine". Central Eurasia studies. Volume 9, Issue 2, October (2016): 231-248 (in Persian)
-European Convention on State Immunity (1972) (in English)
-Explanatory Report to the European Convention on State Immunity (European Treaty Series- No. 74) (1972) (in English)
-Federal Law on Jurisdictional Immunities of Foreign States and the Property of Foreign States in the Russian Federation (2015) (in English)
-Franchini, Daniel, Ukrain Symposium Seizure of Russian State Assets: State Immunity and Countermeasures, Lieber Institute, West Point (Articles of War), (2023) (in English)
-Horst, Ron van  der, Illegal, Unless: Freezing the Assets of Russia s Central Bank, European Journal of International Law, Chad053, (2023) (in English)
-ILC Draft articles on Jurisdictional Immunities of States and Their Property, with Commentaries, (1991) (in English)
-Immenkamp, Beatrix- Leclerc, Gabiga, Russian War on Ukraine: Designating a State as a Sponsor of Terrorism, (2022) (in English)
-Khezri, Seyed Morteza. "State Immunity from the Point of view of International Law", Research Paper of Legal Ideas, Issue 3, (2013): 113- 146 (in Persian)
-Koolaee, Elaheh & Sedaghat , Mohammad. "Ukraine Crisis and the Russian Military Doctrine".  Central Eurasia studies. Volume 10, Issue 1, April (2017): 205-220 (in Persian)
-Mirabasi, Seyed Bagher & Familzavarjalali, Amir." The Jurisdiction of the ICJ on Indication of Provisional Measures: An Emphasis on Ukraine v. Russian Federation 2017". Public Law Studies Quarterly, Vol. 50, No. 4, Winter (2021): 1505- 1524 (in Persian)
-Mosafa, Nasrin. "The United Nations and Future Order", Collected Articles on the Occasion of First Anniversary of the Ukraine War, (2023): 4- 9 (in Persian)
-Niknami, Roxana. "Impact and Effectiveness of Sanctions: The Case of EU Sanction on Russia". Quarterly Foreign Relations, Volume:7 Issue: 25, (2015): 7-38 (in Persian)
-P T zevelekos, Vassilis, Immunities Barring the Prosecution of the Crime of Aggression against Ukrain: European Convention on Human Rights Law Review (2023) (in English)
-Rashidi, Mahnaz. "Russia's legal justifications in the military attack on Ukraine in the crucible of criticism and analysis". Collected Articles on the Occasion of First Anniversary of the Ukraine War, (2023): 96- 98 (in Persian)
-Rostami, Mohammadreza. "Ukraine: Regional Backgrounds an Trans-Regional Consequences". Central Asia and the Caucasus Journal. Volume 20, Issue 85 , May (2014): 35-64 (in Persian)
-S. Kichenina, Victoria- R. Huzin, Artem, Jurisdictional Immunity of the Russian Federation as a Subject of International Private Law (in English)
-Sabaghiyan, Ali & Samoodi, Ali Reza. "EU Sanctions against Russia; Causes, Dimensions and Consequences". Central Asia and The Caucasus Journal. Volume 20, Issue 86 , August (2015), 83-109 (in Persian)
-Samii Isfahani, Alireza & Farahmand Sara. "Russia-Ukraine War and the Future of International Order". Central Asia and The Caucasus Journal. Volume 28, Issue 118 , September (2022): 87-113 (in Persian)
-Shabani Fard, Hamid Reza. "Dialectic of central sovereignty and human rights paradigm in European and Canadian court practice", First Edition, Tehran: Immigrant Publication, (2021) (in Persian)
-Shoaib, Bahman. "Ukraine crisis and the impact of sanctions on the conflict between Russia and the We". Journal of Islamic World Strategic Studies, Volume: 23 Issue: 2, (2023): 135- 154 (in Persian)
Sources and references
-United Nation Convention on the Jurisdictional Immunities of States and Their Property (2004) (in English)
-Zandi, Farzin. "Kremlin in the middle of the sanctions storm; What parts of the Russian economy suffered the most from the war in Ukraine?", Bazar and Capital Magazine, Issue 128, (2022): 64- 64 (in Persian)