Sovereignty and Charted Companies: Objective facts, Subjective Foundations

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Human Sciences Faculty, Shams institute of Higher Education, Gonbad Kavous, Iran.

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Faculty of Law, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.

10.48300/jlr.2022.338985.2057

Abstract

According to the theory of separation of sovereignty from Commercial Activities, companies do not exercise sovereignty; although this theory of French law has not been an accepted principle in all legal systems, including in Iran, where prior to the enactment of the Third Development Plan, public sector companies undertook sovereign duties too. In the seventeenth to nineteenth centuries, the entanglement of sovereignty-entrepreneurship led to granting sovereign, even military powers to concessionaire companies; separation of sovereignty-ownership by France also took place in the nineteenth century, in order to advance colonial goals and to avoid recognition of the rights of the charted companies of other colonial powers. The exercise of corporate sovereignty has always been based on some legal principles: the Christian tradition and the criteria of discoverythe non-ecclesiastical natural law and the criteria of effective custody for recognition of ownership, and then, European public law and criteria of effective custody. In the nineteenth century, domestic public law was the legal system governing charted companies; however, political developments led to the emergence of spheres of influence and the establishment of non-European states; eventually, direct confrontation of European states in the colonial territories led to the formation of nation-states, the elimination of corporate's proxy role despite their efficiency, and the end of charted companies. Nevertheless, in the twentieth century, and especially in the early twenty-first century, International National Companies, with somewhat similar and, of course, non-colonial functions, became the means of exercising the extraterritorial sovereignty of their respective states.

Keywords


  • Almasi, Nejad Ali.Private international law.17th edition.Tehran: Mezan Publishing, 2016. (in Persian)
  • Amin, Abdul Amir.British interests in the Persian Gulf.Translated by Ali Rajabi Yazdi.Tehran: Amir Kabir, (in Persian)
  • Avi-Yonah, Reuven S. «The Cyclical Transformations of the Corporate Form: A Historical Perspective on Corporate Social Responsibility». Delaware Journal of Corporate Law, 30(2005): 767-818. (in English)
  • Blanco, concluded.David, Tribunal of Disputes (1873) .( in French)
  • Bubble Act (1720). (in English)
  • Burns, Tony. « Hegel and Natural Law Theory ». Politics 15(1995):27-32. (in English)
  • Carlos , Ann M.,& Jamie Brown Kruse. « The Decline of the Royal African Company: Fringe Firms and the Role of the Charter ». Economic History Review, 49(1996): 291- 313. (in English)
  • Cattier, Felicien.Study on the situation of the Congo Free State.Brussels: Larcier, 1906.( in French)
  • Chadhuri, Kirti. N. The Trading World of Asia and the English East India Company 1660-1760, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1978. (in English)
  • Charter and Supplement Charter of the Hudson's Bay Company, The Royal Charter for Incorporating the Hudson's Bay Company, (1670). (in English)
  • Charter of the Dutch East Indies Company , Granted by the States General of the United Netherlands, 20 March 1602, Editor Reynders Peter, Translator; Gerristen Rupet, Published by Australia on the Map Division of the Australian Hydrographic Society, (2011). (in English)
  • Charter of the East India Company, Queen Elizabeth, (1600). (in English)
  • Chloros, G . «What Is Natural Law? ».The Modern Law Review 21( 1958):609-622. (in English)
  • Civil service management law;2007 . (in Persian)
  • Cole, Alistair. « State Reform in France: From Public Service to Public Management? ». Perspectives on European Politics and Society journal, 11 (2010): 343-357. (in English)
  • Davenport, Frances Gardiner, , and Charles Oscar Paullin. European Treaties Bearing on the History of the United States and Its Dependencies to 1684 .Washington, D.C. : Carnegie Institution of Washington,1917. (in English)
  • Ditifeci, « The charter of Maryland (JUNE 20, 1632) A Model of proprietary charter ». Il Politico 68(2003): 511-522. (in English)
  • Dum Diversas. «Doctrine of Discovery » Last modified Decembre 30 2019. https://doctrineofdiscovery.org/dum-diversas/.(in English)
  • Duval Claude, Honoré Le Euch, André Pertuzio, & Jacqueline Lang Weaver. International Petroleum Exploration and Exploitation Agreements. New York :Narrows, 2008. (in English)
  • Ehler Sidney Z, & John B. Morrall, trans. Church and State through the centuries: A collection of historic documents with commentaries. New York: Biblo & Tannen Publishers, 1967. (in English)
  • Ellis, George E. « Hudson Bay Company 1670-1870». Journal of the American Geographical Society of New York 18( 1886 ): 127-136. (in English)
  • Gaudemet, Yves. Treatise on administrative law.Volume 1, 16th edition. Paris: L.G.D.J, 2001.( in French)
  • Girault, Arthur, "Colonial Chronicle", Review of public law and political science in France and abroad 8 (1897): 68-89.( in French)
  • Grew , Wilhelm George. The Epochs of International law, New York: walter de gruyter ,2000. (in English)
  • Harari, Yuval Noah.God-like man, a brief history of the future. Translated byZahra Alie.Tehran: Farhang Neshrno in collaboration with Asim Publishing, 2017. (in Persian)
  • Khani-Valizadeh, Saeed. "Criticism of Rai Blanco". Rai Quarterly 21 (2016): 161-175. (in Persian)
  • Koskenniemi ,Marti.The Gentle Civilizer of Nations, The Rise and the Fall of International Law, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001. (in English)
  • «Home» last modified March 29, 2022.https://www.larousse.fr/encyclopedia/divers/service_public/187160.( in French)
  • Law of the fourth program of economic, social and cultural development,2004. (in Persian)
  • Law of the third program of economic, social and cultural development; (in Persian)
  • Law on the implementation of general policies of Article 44 of the Constitution;2008 (in Persian).
  • Linden, H. Vander. «Alexander VI. and the Demarcation of the Maritime and Colonial Domains of Spain and Portugal, 1493-1494». The American Historical Review, 22 (1916): 1–20. (in English)
  • Lucassen, Jan. « A Multinational and its Labour Force: The Dutch East India Company 1595-1795».International Labor and Working-Class History 66(2004): 12-39. (in English)
  • Maps of Liberia, 1830 to 1870, History Of Liberia: A Time Line 1820 to 1847, Library of Congress, Digital Collections,(1997). (in English)
  • McLean, Janet . "The Transnational Corporation in History: Lessons for Today?," Indiana Law Journal , 79(2004) : 363-377. (in English)
  • Mitchell, John, Valérie Marcel, & Beth Mitchell. What Next for the Oil and Gas Industry, London: Chatham House,2012. (in English)
  • Mousavi Dalini, Javad and Mohammad Ali Ranjbar. The role of the British East India Company in changing the political and economic position of Iran in the Persian Gulf. History of Islam and Iran 18 (2012): 15-35. (in Persian)
  • Nabob of Arcot v. E. India Co. (1793). (in English)
  • Nili Pourtabatabai, Seyedakbar, Saeed Khazaei, and Habib Elah Fatahi Ardakani, "Recognizing the government's governance duties and its importance in setting strategic plans and monitoring the performance of institutions (examination of challenges, solutions, efforts made in this regard)" . Journal of Accounting and Auditing Research 45 (2019): 41-54. (in Persian)
  • Nys, Ernest. The Congo Free State and International Law.Brussels: Hayez, 1903.( in French)
  • Oregon Ry. & Nav. Co. v. Oregonian Ry. Co. (1889). (in English)
  • Pillet, Antione, & Paul Fauchille, “International law at the beginning of the 20th century”.General Review of Public International Law, 8(1901): 400-408.( in French)
  • Pormahmayun, Ali-Asghar. "Practice of governance and tenure." Journal of Legal Collection 173 (1940 ): 789-791. (in Persian)
  • Roukis, George S. « The British East India Company 1600-1858, a model of transition management for the modern global corporation ». The Journal of Management Development 23 (2004): 938-948. (in English)
  • Royal Exchange and London Assurance Corporation Act (1719). (in English)
  • Sahni, Binda. « A Legal Analysis of the British East India Company ». Acta Juridica Hungarica 4 (2013): 317-330. (in English)
  • Scott ,William Henry. « Demythologizing the Papal Bull Tater Cactera». Philippine 'Studies 35 (1987): 348-356. (in English)
  • Scott ,William. Robert. «The Constitution and Finance of the Royal African Company of England from its Foundation Till 1720». The American Historical Review 8( 1903): 241–259. (in English)
  • Seal, culture.For-profit institutions and public companies.Tehran: Faculty of Administrative Sciences and Business Management, University of Tehran Publications,   (in Persian)
  • Spector, Celine.Power and sovereignty in the history of Western thought.second edition .Translated by Abbas Bagheri.Tehran: Ney Publishing, 2019. (in Persian)
  • Sutton, Jean. «The English East India Company; The Historical Perspective». The International Journal of Nautical Archaeology and Underwater Exploration, 19(1990): 5-12. (in English)
  • Tatari, Ali. "Agreement of 1907 AD, Exploitation or Independence". Foreign Relations Quarterly 49 (2010): 111-136. (in Persian)
  • The financial program of the government;The fifth development plan of the country (revised) 1352-1356;1975 ;National Assembly. (in Persian)
  • The general policies of the development of the non-governmental sector, by handing over activities and state enterprises;2006 . (in Persian)
  • The History of Hudson Bay Company ,Published by Permission of the Governor and Committee of the Hudson's Bay Company, Polar Record,(1935). (in English)
  • The Law of the Fifth Development Plan of the country (revised) 1352-1356;1975 .(in Persian)
  • the law on determining the authority of claims between individuals and the government;1930 . (in Persian)
  • The law on determining the authority of claims between individuals and the government;1928 . (in Persian)
  • The Papal Bull Inter Caetera; Pope Alexander VI, (1493). (in English)
  • Travers, Twiss, The Law of Nations Considered as Independent Political Communities,Oxford: Clarendon Press,1884. (in English)
  • Treaty of Alcáçovas; Spain-Portugal, ( 1479). (in English)
  • Vaezi, Seyed mojatbi. "Criteria of Sovereignty in Administrative Law of Iran". Journal of Legal Studies of Shiraz University 2(2014): 199-220. (in Persian)
  • Van Der Kroef , Justus M. «The Decline and Fall of the Dutch East India Company» The Historian 10(1948): 118-134. (in English)
  • Waisberg, Tatiana. «The Treaty of Tordesillas and the (re)Invention of International Law in the Age of Discovery ». Journal of Global Sudies, 18(2017): 1-12. (in English)
  • Westlake, John. Chapters on the Principles of International law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1894. (in English)
  • Wheaton, Henry. Elements of International Law with a Sketch of the History of Science, London: Felloewes, 1836. (in English)