Journal of Legal Research

Journal of Legal Research

Differentiation of Documented and Justification of Judicial Opinions

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Associate Professor, Department of Jurisprudence and Fundamentals of Islamic Law, Faculty of Theology and Islamic Studies, University of Sistan & Baluchistan, Zahedan, Iran.
2 PhD student in Jurisprudence and Fundamentals of Islamic Law, Faculty of Theology and Islamic Studies, University of Sistan & Baluchistan, Zahedan, Iran.
Abstract
One of the principles of fair proceedings is the principle of documentary and reasoned judicial decisions. The importance of this principle is so great that its failure to be considered by the judicial authority has been identified as one of the cases of voting violations. Given that the observance of this principle has been emphasized in the constitution, civil and criminal procedure, and even as an accepted principle in quasi-judicial authorities, such as the law on handling administrative violations, the law on handling violations of the armed forces, and the tax law. is, the analysis of the nature of the words documented and substantiated to explain the difference between the two in order to resolve some ambiguities is considered one of the goals of this article. This research, which was carried out with a descriptive-analytical method, shows that the explanation of each of the two words and the purpose of the legislator regarding these words is a legal gap that is considered necessary to be addressed. Therefore, it can be said that created causation, inherent authenticity, objective process, credibility in judicial matters and the judge's responsibility to discover the facts are considered to be documentary features, and in contrast to demonstrative causality, fake authenticity, mental process, credibility in subjective matters. And the claimant's mission in this field are considered to be well-reasoned approaches.
Keywords

references
1- Ibn Sina, Hossein bin Abda.... Warnings and Warnings. C1. Qom: Book Publishing. 1377. [in Arabic]
2- Bojunordi, Hassan. Rules of Jurisprudence, Volume 3. Qom: Hadi Publishing. 1419. [in Arabic]
3- Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jaafar. Extensive in legal terminology. Tehran: Ganj Danesh. 1381 .[in persian]
4 Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jaafar.  Legal terminology. Tehran: Ganj Danesh. 1370. [in persian]
5 Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jaafar.  Encyclopaedia of law. Ch5. Tehran: Amir Kabir. 1375. [in persian]
6 Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jaafar. The art of reasoning in the logic of Islamic law. Tehran: Ganj Danesh. 1382. [in persian]
7- Jurjani, Seyyed Sharif. Description of positions. Qom: Sharif al-Razi. 1370. [in Arabic]
8- Jarr, Khalil, translator Seyyed Hamid Tabibian. Translation of Al-Mu'jam al-Arabi al-Hadith. C2. Tehran: Amir Kabir. 1365. [in persian]
9- Jafari Tabar, Hassan. Philosophical foundations of legal interpretation. Tehran: Publishing Company. 1383. [in persian]
10- Khomeini, Seyyed Rouh A.... Anwar al-Hadaye. Qom: Imam Khomeini Publishing Institute. 1415. [in Arabic]
11- Khalilian, Khalil. Legal claims of Iran and the United States in the Hague Court of Arbitration. Tehran: Publishing Company. 1382. [in persian]
12- Diyani, Abdul Rasul. Proof of litigation in civil and criminal matters. Tehran: Teaching. 1358. [in persian]
13- Diyani, Abdul Rasul.  Iqhan conscience of the judge, a brief comparison of Islamic legal systems". Judicial Journal, 51. (1384). [in persian]
14- Daftari, Ahmed Mateen. Civil and commercial procedure, Tehran: Majd. 1381. [in persian]
 15- Dehkhoda, Ali Akbar. dictionary. C8. Tehran: Tehran University Press. 1373. [in persian]
16- Zarkashi, Muhammad bin Abda... Al-Bahr al-Muhait fi Usul al-Fiqh. Qom: Darul Kitab. 1414. [in Arabic]
17- Sabzevari, Mulla Hadi. Description of the system. Tehran Iran. 1371. [in persian]
18- Sobhani, Jafar. The product of science. Qom: Imam Sadegh Educational and Research Institute. 1381. [in Arabic]
19- Suhravardi, Shahabuddin. Illumination wisdom. Qom: Bostan Kitab. 2012. [in persian]
20- Soodmandi, Abdul Majid. "Analysis of substantiated and undocumented cases of the votes of the General Board of the Court of Administrative Justice and its legal consequences". Legal Journal of Justice. 83. 108. 2018. [in persian]
21- Shirazi, Sadrul Matalhin. Asfar Arbaah C3. Qom: Mustafavi. 1380. [in persian]
22- Shirazi, Sadrul Matalhin.  Al-Hikma al-Muttaliyyah fi al-Isfar al-Aqliyyah. Beirut: Dar al-Ahiya al-Trath al-Arabi. 1981. [in Arabic]
23- Martyr Thani, Zainuddin bin Ali. Masalak Al-Afham to revision of the Sharia of Islam. Qom: Islamic Education Foundation. 1413. [in Arabic]
24- Shams, Abda..... Civil procedure. Tehran: Mizan. 1382. [in Arabic]
25- Sadrzadeh Afshar, Sayyed Mohsen. Proof of litigation in Iranian law. Tehran: Academic Publishing Center. 1369. [in Arabic]
26- Sadegh Menesh, Jafar. "The basis, method and place of judicial reasoning". Legal Journal of Justice. 79. 1391. [in Arabic]
27- Sangour Bahrani, Mohammad. Al-Mujajm al-Asuli. Beirut: Al-Mosseh al-Tarikh al-Arabi. 1342. [in Arabic]
28- Askari, Abu Hilal. Al-Farooq al-Language. Qom: Society of teachers. 1412. [in Arabic]
29- Allameh Hali, Hassan bin Yusuf. The essence of Nadeed. Qom: Wake up. 1371. [in Arabic]
30- Amirnia, Mohammad Bagher and Jamadi, Ali. "Referring to the spirit of the law in proceedings". Journal of Legal Studies of Shiraz University. 9. 1. 2016. [in persian]
31- Osman, Mahmoud Hamed. Al-Qamoos al-Mubin fi terms of al-Asuliyyin. First Edition. Riyadh: Dar al-Zahm. 1423. [in Arabic]
32- Ameli (Shahidavel), Muhammad bin Makki. Al-Dros al-Sharia fi fiqh al-Umamiyah. Qom: Society of Seminary Teachers. 1412. [in Arabic]
33- Amrwani, Rahman. "Conflict of evidence to prove the case". Doctoral thesis of University of Tehran. 1390. [in persian]
34- Arif Ali, Majid, Arif Ali. "Concept and theoretical foundations of the necessity of reasoning in the civil judgments of the courts". International Conference on Law and Judicial Sciences. 129. 2019. [in persian]
35- Fayoumi, Ahmad bin Muhammad. Misbah Al-Munir Qom: Dar al-Hijrah. 1425. [in Arabic]
36- Qaramelki, Farmarz. Logic 1. Tehran: Payam Noor. 1384. [in persian]
37- Katouzian, Nasser. Proof and reason for proof. C1. Tehran: Mizan. 1385. [in persian]
38- Katouzian, Nasser. Introduction to the science of law and study in Iran's private law. Tehran: Ganj Danesh. 1366. [in persian]
39- Katouzian, Nasser. The basics of law. Ch51. Tehran: Publishing Company. 1385. [in persian]
40- Katouzian, Nasser. Philosophy of law, Tehran: publishing company. 1385. [in persian]
41- Katouzian, Nasser. Validity of the adjudicated matter in civil lawsuits. Tehran: Mizan. 1383. [in persian]
42- Ketabi Roudi, "Ahmed and Mohammad Reza Special, The Limits of the Jurisdiction of the Court of Administrative Justice in the Appointment of Managers of Public Non-Governmental Institutions", Perspectives on Judicial Laws, 65, (2013). [in persian].
43- Karimi, Abbas. Code of Civil Procedure, Tehran: Majd. 1386. [in persian]
44- Makarem Shirazi, Naser. Jurisprudence rules. C2. Qom: Amir al-Mominin school. 1411. [in Arabic]
45- Madani, Seyed Jalaluddin. Evidence to prove the case. Tehran: Ganj Danesh. 1370. [in persian]
46- Maalouf, Lewis. Al-Munjad in Al-Laghe. Tehran: Islam. 1382. [in Arabic]
47- Motahari, Morteza. Detailed description of the system. Tehran: Sadra. 2018. [in persian]
48- Motahari, Morteza.  collection. C5. Tehran: Sadra. 1376. [in persian]
49- Mohagheq Damad, Mustafa. The rules of jurisprudence. Tehran: University Science Center. 1406. [in persian]
50- Misbah Yazdi, Mohammad Taghi. Teaching philosophy. C1. Tehran: Amir Kabir. 2016. [in persian]
51- Mohseni, Mohsin. Bar association magazine. 21. 2014. [in persian]
52- Mostafavi, Hassan. Researching the words of the Holy Qur'an. C3. Beirut-Cairo: Dar al-Kitab al-Alamiya. 1368. [in Arabic]
53-  Muzaffar, Mohammad Reza. Principles of jurisprudence. C2. Ch 5. Qom: Ismailian. 1375. [in persian]
54- Mutoli, Kazem. Public opinion and methods of persuasion. Tehran: Behjat. 1384. [in persian]
55- Mohmasani, Sobhi Rajab. Legislative philosophy in Islam. Tehran: Works of Andisheh. 1386. [in persian]
56- Nowrozi Chakli, Abdul Reza. Familiarity with scientometrics. Tehran. Organization of study and editing of university science books. Shahid University: Printing and Publishing Center. 1390. [in persian]
57- Niknejad, Javad. "Justified, documented and substantiated judgment of the court and arbitration", researches of private law. 9. 35. 1400. [in persian]
58- Hormazi, Khaira..... "Appeals from civil decisions and the supervisory role of the Supreme Court in the correct implementation of the law". (Doctoral dissertation on private law, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, University of Tehran, under the guidance of Prof. Katouzian. 2013). [in persian]
59- Hashemi, Seyyed Jafar. A comparative study of the principles of civil trials in the constitutional laws and the Islamic Republic of Iran. Tehran: Islamic Revolution Documentation Center. 1378. [in persian]
60- Yelfani, Ali Akbar. Description and interpretation of civil procedure laws. Tehran: Amir Kabir. 1380. [in persian]
61- Black,henry. law dictionary. eighth edition.west publishing co. new york. 2004. [in English]
62- Levy, prof. judicial review of fact questions. administrative law review. vol,4.2005. [in English]
63- gabrial, marty, la distinction du fait et du droit, l e semain juridque, 1974. [in English]
64- zuckerman, a.s adrain, law fact our justices, boston university law revew, 1986. [in English]